Why catcher in the rye is controversial

Schuch argued that:. The book is filled with profanity and obscenity. We want students to use appropriate language. So why should they study inappropriate language? Lennon was asked to sign a copy of The Catcher in the Rye the morning by his murderer the morning of his assassination. The book contains no evidence that it could possibly have had anything to do with leading Chapman to murder John Lennon, however, as a result that it was The Catcher in the Rye , a book describing a nervous breakdown, media thought deeply about the possible connections, giving the book yet another reason for people to arguer to ban the book Banks.

There have been many complaints made against The Catcher in the Rye. Vulgarity is one complaint The Catcher in the Rye gets over and over again. Holden swears steadily throughout the book. Today, most of the cursing in the book would not even be considered PG if it were put in a movie.

Too much vulgarity seems like a rather ridiculous excuse to ban a book. Swearing is not something new; on the contrary, cursing can be traced back more than five centuries. In March and April of , researchers went to Portsmouth High School to research the amount of vulgarity used among students while walking around campus. When monitoring the use of foul language in one lunch period, the researchers recorded an average of twenty-nine curse words in the twenty-eight minute lunchtime, just in the section of the school the observers were monitoring Jacques.

Researchers then administered a survey to teachers and students based on a one to five scale; one being never and five being all the time. The survey results showed that the average of hearing cursing in the foyer was 4. Here the results showed that the average amount of swearing among students was 3. These include an episode with a pimp and a prostitute with whom Holden does not have sex and a visit to an old teacher, Mr.

Antolini, who gets drunk and makes what Holden interprets as a sexual advance. In recent years, the novel has also been blamed for promoting alienation among students responsible for high-school shootings. Nevertheless, Catcher in the Rye is widely regarded as one of the most important contributions to American literature since the end of World War II.

This article was originally published in He has published articles and book chapters on obscenity, copyright, criminal procedure, legal fictions, and the history of the common law.

Steinle, Pamela Hunt. Robert John Bardo, another killer, was carrying a copy of the book the night he murdered actress Rebecca Schaeffer. You don't have to be a murderer to like it, though. Salinger could have been a meat importer — his father was a successful meat and cheese merchant who sent his son to Austria to brush up on the trade before the second world war.

Luckily, Salinger left after only a month, escaping both the meat trade and the Nazis. The American rock band Green Day are proud champions of Salinger's antihero; their song Basket Case is a nasally homage in nasally whines.

They also named an earlier song Who Wrote Holden Caulfield? Presumably they couldn't find a rhyme for Salinger.